IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA GAUTENG LOCAL DIVISION, JOHANNESBURG
TUESDAY, 02ND JUNE	2020

OPPOSED MOTION

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE VAN OOSTEN J BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE KATHREE-SETILOANE J BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE WEINER J
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MANOIM AJ BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE BOTHA AJ BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE NATHAN AJ UNOPPOSED MOTION
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE THOMPSON AJ

URGENT APPLICATIONS

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE VALLY J
2020/10086 HERMIONE NELL v CONSTANTIA INSURANCE GROUP LTD BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE KEIGHTLEY J BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MODIBA J
SPECIAL MOTION

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE WEPENER J

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MOKGOATHLENG J AND BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE OPPERMAN J S v LM AND OTHERS

INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE ADAMS J

TAX COURT

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE TSOKA J

SUMMARY JUDGMENT/RULE 43

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE BONTHUYS AJ

CRIMINAL APPEALS

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE LAMONT J AND BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE DOSIO AJ A54/2018

FULL COURT APPEAL: CRIMINAL

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MNGQIBISA-THUSI J AND BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE DE VILLIERS AJ AND BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MTATI AJ		
A353/2016		
CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCES		
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MOLAHLEHI J		
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE COETZEE AJ		
CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCES/SETTLEMENT COURT		
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MOORCROFT AJ		
CIVIL TRIALS		
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE COPPIN J	4	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE FRANCIS J	
4	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE VALLY J	
10	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE WINDELL J	
4	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE FISHER J	
4	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MAHALELO J	
4	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE DIPPENAAR J	
4	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE YACOOB J	
4	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE STRYDOM J	
9	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE SENYATSI J	
9	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE LOUW AJ	
4	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MOOSA AJ	
4	

BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUDGE MATHUNZI AJ	
4	

THE CIVIL TRIAL ROLL BEFORE SUTHERLAND ADJP.

Allocations:

IN TERMS OF PARAGRAPH 8 OF THE JUDGE PRESIDENT’S DIRECTIVE OF 11 MAY 2020 THERE SHALL BE NO PHYSICAL TRIAL ROLL. PARTIES MUST COMPLY STRICTLY WITH THE PROVISIONS OF PARAGRAPH 8 OF THE DIRECTIVE OF 24 APRIL 2020. PARTIES SHALL BE NOTIFIED OF ALLOCATIONS BY EMAIL.

NUMBER ON
ROLL	CASE NO	PARTIES	ALLOCATION	
MATTERS IN WHICH A CERTIFICATE OF READINESS HAS BEEN ISSUED	
	
1	2018/27436	MUTHOMBENE ROSITA v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND
Counsel:
Plaintiff: Mr N E Komana Defendant: Unknown Quantum
PRACTICE NOTE FILED ON 29 MAY 2020 AT 14H54 (OUT OF TIME)	Matter is removed from the roll. The practice note was filed out of time.	
2	2018/27385	PRESTON RAYMOND WILLIAM v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	
3	2016/21889	TOORIE CHARLENE v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND
Counsel
Plaintiff: Adv G J Strydom SC Defendant: Mr T Potsoane (Attorney)
Quantum (past medical expenses; loss of earnings; general damages)
Argument on the papers with heads of argument	Yacoob J
Secretary: Ms B Mashamba E-mail:
BMashamba@judiciary.org.za	
4	2016/41059	BASSON ASHTON MICHAEL v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	

5	2018/06546	MAANDAMELA MASHUDU OWEN v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May 2020.	
6	2017/10091	FLORENCE HAPPY MANGETHE v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	
7	2016/43054	SIMON LUNGA v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	
8	2019/32341	UMARINE MONTSE TSHIMANO v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND
Counsel
Plaintiff: Ms L R Molope (Attorney)
Defendant: Mr D Weideman (Attorney)
Merits and quantum Issues in dispute: Plaintiff’s locus standi; Videoconferencing – MS Teams/Zoom	SENYATSI J
Secretary: Ms N. Khulu E-mail: Nkhulu@judiciary.org.za	
9	2018/23570	SHAKWANE CLARA v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	
10	2018/26045	MAHLEKETE ZEPHANIA v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND
Counsel:
Plaintiff: Adv L Swart Defendant: No counsel appointed
Merits and quantum (general damages; future loss of income; contingencies Estimated duration: 3 – 4 days R37 pre-trial conference held: 14 November 2019
Zoom/MS Teams	Wait to be allocated – unavailability of judges	

11	2016/25703	BHERO RACHEL TENDAYI v MEC FOR HEALTH, GAUTENG
Counsel
Plaintiff: Adv C Vallaro Defendant: not yet appointed Medical negligence Quantum
Estimated duration: 4 days R37 pre-trial conference held: 15 November 2019
Minutes filed: 04 December 2019
Zoom/MS Teams	Windell J
Secretary: Ms A. du Toit E-mail: ADuToit@judiciary.org.za	
12	2012/29598	TEBOHO DANIEL MOLAETSA v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	
13	2016/33852	MAMPE MADU ELIZABETH v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND
Counsel
Plaintiff: Adv N Motala Defendant: Unknown Quantum (general damages) Heads of argument
R37 pre-trial conferences held: 03 May 2018; 31
January 2020 and 19 May
2020
Minutes registered: 08 May 2018; 04 February 2020 and
22 May 2020
Videoconferencing – Zoom/MS Teams Estimated duration: 1 – 2 hours	Yacoob J
Secretary: Ms B Mashamba E-mail:
BMashamba@judiciary.org.za	
14	2016/15665	QONDISILE DEBRA NKOSI v MEC FOR HEALTH, GAUTENG
Counsel
Plaintiff: Adv D T v R du Plessis SC and Adv A Naidoo Defendant: Adv V Notshe SC and Adv K Pheto
Medical negligence Quantum (general damages)
Estimated duration: 4 – 5 days R37 pre-trial conference: 06 November 2018 and 29
January 2020 Videoconferencing: Zoom	Louw AJ
Secretary: Ms S. Pholo E-mail: SPholo@judiciary.org.za	
OTHER MATTERS	

15	2018/36145	JOHN HENRY HELMAND v JOSE MARIA FALCAO PIRES	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May 2020.	
16	2016/23498	ENJIMKONYE JUSTIN v EKURHULENI METROPOLITAN MUNICIPALITY	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	
17	2016/13756	MANUEL ADELINO DE ATOUGUIA v LURDES LIDIA DE ATOUGUIA	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	
18	2015/18903	THOKOZANI P HADEBE v MINISTER OF POLICE	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May 2020.	
19	7/25376	KHUMALO CHRISTINA FUNDISWA v MINISTER OF POLICE
Counsel
Plaintiff: Adv N Mabena Defendant: Unknown Estimated duration: 5 days R37 pre-trial conference held: 10 February 2020
Unlawful arrest and assault Audio-visual conference and by affidavits	Tsoka J
Secretary: Ms P. van Wyk E-mail: PVanWyk@judiciary.org.za	
20	2017/22722	TELEKOA MAMOIPONE ANNA v CITY OF JOHANNESBURG	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	

21	2016/27854	MARKOS BROTHERS CC v JOHANNA GEORGINA NANDE
Counsel
Plaintiff: Adv M De Oliveira Defendant: Adv R Shepstone Videoconferencing – MS Teams
Estimated duration: 1 – 2 days Misrepresentation that give rise to a right to resile from the Sale Agreement	Dippenaar J
Secretary: Ms E. Govender E-mail: EGovender@judiciary.org.za	
22	2017/09183	EDMUND SIKUMBUZO MARAMBANA v ALZINAH THOKO MARAMBANA	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	
23	2017/12223	SELLO MOANE ERIC v PASSENGER RAIL AGENCY OF SOUTH AFRICA	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	
24	2015/30919	NICOLAAS GABRIEL BRONKHORST v LEON JJ VAN RENSBURG ATTORNEYS	Matter is struck off from the roll of 02 June 2020. No practice note was filed in terms of the Judge
President’s Consolidated Practice Directive in re Court Operations and post extended Covid-19 National Lockdown dated 11 May
2020.	
MATTERS ENROLLED (RAF)	
25	2019/5762	FURUMELE NOMSA ELIZABETH v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND
Counsel:
Plaintiff: Adv J Killian Defendant: Unknown Merits
Case management conference held: 27 May 2020 Certified on merits	Fisher J
Secretary: Ms P. Ramoshaba E-mail: PRamoshaba@judiciary.org.za	

26	2019/2832	SIBANDA ANELE v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND
Counsel:
Plaintiff: Adv G Benson Defendant: Mr C Shirilele (Attorney)
Estimated duration: 1 day R37 pre-trial conference held: 22 May 2020
Judicial case management conference: 26 May 2020 Merits and quantum (future medical expenses; past and future loss of earnings) Zoom/MS Teams	Francis-Subbiah AJ Secretary: Mr E. Malematja E-mail: Emalematja@judiciary.org.za	
MATTERS REMOVED FROM THE ROLL BY NOTICE	

PRACTICE NOTES RECEIVED, MATTERS NOT ON THE ROLL, COURT FILES ARE NOT WITH ROLL CALLING JUDGE
Kindly approach the registrar, Ms T. Khumalo (TKhumalo@judiciary.org.za /010 494 8397) with the necessary documentation and a request that the matter be enrolled.

If the registrar approve the enrolment, the matter may be enrolled and dealt with.	
	2019/01978	MTHANTI MLAMULI ERNEST v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND
Counsel
Plaintiff: Adv J S Maisela Defendant: Unknown
R37 pre-trial held: 07 May 2020
Quantum (general damages; future loss of earnings or earning capacity) Teleconference – Zoom/MS Teams	Removed	
	2016/23309	MABHAYE SINOTHANDO v ROAD ACCIDENT FUND
Counsel
Plaintiff: Adv M L Mataboge Defendant: No counsel
R37 pre-trial conference held: 29 November 2018 (more than 18 months ago) Estimated duration: 1 – 2 days Quantum (general damages; future medical expenses; loss of earnings/earning capacity)	Removed